Wisconsin Supreme Court upholds state home stay order

Wisconsin Supreme Court upholds state home stay order
Wisconsin Supreme Court upholds state home stay order

The Wisconsin Supreme Court on Wednesday rejected the state home stay order during the coronovirus epidemic as "illegal, invalid and inaccessible," saying the Secretary of State for Health exceeded his authority.

In a 4-3 ruling, the court directed Health Services Secretary Andrea Palm, known as Emergency Order 28, "a substantial seizure of power".

The order states that everyone in the state has been instructed to stay at home or at their place of residence, subject only to the exceptions allowed by Pam, the ruling says. The order, which was to last until May 26, banned travel and business, as well as fines for non-compliance with jail time or intimidation.

The ruling says the judges were not challenging the emergency powers of Democratic government Tony Evers, but the decision effectively undermines his administration and forces him to strike an agreement with the Republican-controlled Legislature.

One of the dissident judges, Rebecca Dellett, said her conservative colleagues were mostly those who had exceeded their authority, and cited an example for Pam's instructions to stay in a house during the Spanish epidemic of 1918 Was the order. .

Undoubtedly, this decision would be considered one of the clearest examples of judicial activism in the history of this court, "said." And it will be the residents of Wisconsin who pay the price. "

The decision is a result of the Legislature's lawsuit against the Department of Health Services that Pam's instructions went too far and requested the court to relieve the Legislature in the "seat at the table" process. Development of standards.

During oral arguments, Judge Rebecca Bradley suggested that the order was given for "atrocities" and that, at other times, Japanese Americans were under house arrest during World War II.

Supreme Court President Patience Roggensak actively questioned both sides and was later criticized for halting the increase in JBS meat packaging cases in Green Bay.

However, in response to the Department of Disease, Rogasek said the spikes in the cases were "due to the packaging of the meat. This is where the Brown County outbreak occurred. It was not just common people in Brown County." De Salud highlighted the spread of the virus.

According to the NBC News Coronavirus Tracker, approximately 11,000 and 421 deaths of COVID-19 have been confirmed in Wisconsin.

Leaders of the Republican Legislature said in a statement after the ruling, "Republicans believe business owners can safely reopen using guidelines provided by the Wisconsin Economic Development Corporation."

"Until now, Wisconsin had a very good place in our fight against COVID-19," Evers said.

"We cannot allow today's decision to do all the work we have done and all the sacrifices that the people of Wisconsin have made in recent months," he said in a statement. "I am disappointed with today's decision, but our top priority has been and what we can and do want to do to protect the health and safety of the people in our state."

Post a Comment